Switzerland Won 4–0 Without Xhaka. Control Is Another Question.

MATCHIQ / FOOTBALL DECISION INTELLIGENCE · 足球决策情报

Published by MATCHIQ / 由 MATCHIQ 发布

MATCHIQ graphic featuring Remo Freuler, Alvyn Sanches and Murat Yakin, comparing Switzerland's 0–0 draw with Slovenia and 4–0 victory over Scotland.

For the opening 20 minutes in St Gallen, Scotland were making Switzerland work.

They pressed high, challenged for possession and gave Murat Yakin’s side little reason to expect a comfortable evening. Unlike their previous meeting in September, Scotland still had eleven players on the pitch.

Then, in the 22nd minute, Zachary Athekame sent the ball into the Scottish penalty area. Lewis Ferguson tried to deal with it but turned it into his own net.

Switzerland were ahead.

By the final whistle, they had won 4–0, with three more goals arriving after half-time.

Granit Xhaka had not played a minute. Once again, Switzerland had found a way to win without the midfielder who had spent years helping them control matches.

The result was impressive. It was also more useful evidence than September’s 3–0 victory over Scotland, when an early red card had given Switzerland a numerical advantage.

But the score raised a question that could not be answered by looking at the goals alone.

Switzerland had proved they could win without Xhaka. Had they also learned how to control matches without relying on one central organiser?

The first Scotland victory had left doubts

Switzerland’s Nations League campaign had begun strongly.

They opened with a 3–0 win over North Macedonia before travelling to Scotland on 29 September.

That match looked like another convincing result on paper. Switzerland won 3–0, kept a clean sheet and maintained their perfect start.

Yet Scotland had been reduced to ten men after Jack Hendry received a red card with the score still 0–0.

For almost 80 minutes, Switzerland played with an extra man.

That changed the nature of the contest. Scotland had less freedom to press, fewer players to cover passing lanes and a greater need to protect space.

Switzerland deserved credit for making their advantage count, but the game could not offer a complete test of their midfield against equal numbers.

A few days later, Slovenia presented a different problem.

Switzerland fell behind and had to recover the match. They eventually won 2–1, with Dan Ndoye scoring the winner.

For a team missing Xhaka, that comeback mattered. It showed the players could respond when the match was no longer going according to plan.

In October, MATCHIQ examined whether Switzerland were beginning to share some of Xhaka’s responsibilities across the team.

For years, Xhaka had been the player teammates could turn to when possession became difficult. He helped move the ball out of defence, decided when to speed up or slow down and offered a familiar reference point under pressure.

Without him, Switzerland were still winning.

Perhaps those responsibilities were starting to belong to more players.

It was a reasonable possibility, but the evidence came with limits. Scotland’s early red card had affected one victory. Other opponents had made costly defensive mistakes.

The wins were real. What produced Switzerland’s control was harder to establish.

Xhaka was not being replaced by choice

There was another detail worth keeping clear.

Yakin had not decided that Switzerland would be better off without their captain.

After Xhaka’s earlier absence from the national team, the Swiss Football Association confirmed on 27 October that he could return and would retain the captaincy.

His absence in November came for a different reason.

On 10 November, the association announced that Xhaka would miss the final international window of the year because of a calf injury.

Johan Manzambi, another midfield option who had contributed during the campaign, was also unavailable because of a calf problem.

Yakin therefore had to prepare for the final two matches without either player.

It created another opportunity to assess Switzerland’s midfield, although not an experiment the coach had deliberately designed.

And the two fixtures offered strikingly different evidence.

Against Slovenia, Switzerland had the ball but not the goal

On 13 November, Switzerland travelled to Slovenia knowing a draw would be enough to secure promotion to Nations League A.

They got the result they needed.

The match ended 0–0.

According to the Swiss Football Association, Switzerland finished with 72% possession, completed 780 passes and attempted 13 shots, four on target.

Those numbers describe a team that spent considerable time on the ball.

But Slovenia remained difficult to break down.

They defended compactly and looked for chances on the counterattack. One Slovenian effort ended in the net before being ruled out for offside. Switzerland also threatened late, with Ndoye narrowly missing after a counterattack.

The match demonstrated that Switzerland could keep possession for long periods without Xhaka.

It did not establish that they could consistently create clear openings against an organised defence.

There is an important difference between deciding where the ball spends most of the match and deciding where the next good chance comes from.

Against Slovenia, Switzerland managed the first task much better than the second.

The draw secured promotion, so Yakin had achieved the immediate objective. Still, it left questions about how his side would turn prolonged possession into goals.

Three days later, Scotland offered a very different contest.

Four goals came from different situations

Switzerland had already secured first place when Scotland arrived in St Gallen.

Yakin rotated his starting team. Remo Freuler captained the side, with Ardon Jashari alongside him in midfield. Samuel Ballet, Winsley Boteli and Alvyn Sanches were among those given attacking responsibilities.

Scotland began energetically and pressed Switzerland high up the pitch.

The visitors also created danger. John McGinn forced Yvon Mvogo into a save with a header before half-time.

Switzerland’s opening goal, meanwhile, came from Ferguson’s mistake.

It was the result of a dangerous delivery into the box, but an own goal cannot by itself demonstrate that Switzerland had found a reliable method of opening up a settled defence.

After half-time, the Swiss attack became more productive.

In the 47th minute, Ballet helped create the move that Boteli finished near the goal line.

Four minutes later, Switzerland won possession and moved forward quickly. Sanches received the ball in space and finished to make it 3–0.

That third goal highlighted a valuable quality. Switzerland recognised the moment to attack after a turnover and took advantage before Scotland could recover their defensive positions.

The fourth arrived late. Sanches found substitute Zeki Amdouni, whose effort took a deflection before reaching the net.

Four goals, but not four examples of the same attacking pattern.

An own goal, a move finished near the goal line, a rapid transition and a deflected shot had all contributed.

Switzerland showed that they could threaten in different ways.

What the goals did not reveal was whether several midfielders were now consistently sharing the deeper work Xhaka used to perform: receiving under pressure, progressing possession and controlling the tempo against strong opposition.

Winning control and controlling a game are not identical

Switzerland deserved their victory.

They defended effectively, converted opportunities and became increasingly comfortable after establishing a substantial lead.

Freuler and his teammates managed the later stages without needing Xhaka to organise every moment.

That is genuine progress for a side accustomed to relying on such an experienced midfielder.

But Scotland did not spend the entire match chasing shadows.

Besides McGinn’s first-half header, Ferguson and Scott McTominay had opportunities later on, although neither found the target.

Nor should Switzerland’s greater comfort at 3–0 be confused with their ability to impose the same control while the score was level.

When a team leads by three goals, its opponent has to take more risks. That often creates additional room for possession and counterattacks.

At 0–0 against Slovenia, Switzerland had faced a more patient defensive opponent and failed to score despite dominating the ball.

Both performances can be true reflections of the same team.

The Swiss are becoming difficult to beat without Xhaka. They can protect a lead and exploit the space an opponent leaves behind.

Whether they can repeatedly dictate a difficult game from the beginning, against opponents who press effectively and defend with eleven players, remains less certain.

There is another explanation for Switzerland’s success

Perhaps the most important change is not that Switzerland have distributed Xhaka’s control duties.

Perhaps they have simply become more effective at winning matches through disciplined defending, quick transitions and improved finishing.

That would still be valuable.

A national team does not have to dominate possession in every fixture to succeed. Some opponents are better attacked quickly, especially when they commit players forward.

Scotland’s pressing created one kind of game. Slovenia’s compact defending created another.

Switzerland handled the former more decisively.

Their recent results therefore offer evidence of adaptability and effectiveness, without proving precisely how the central midfield operates across different match situations.

To establish that, we would need to examine repeated passing sequences rather than just possession totals and goals.

Who offers the first passing option when the centre-backs are pressed? Does progression consistently move through Freuler or Jashari, or do several players take responsibility? Who slows the game when Switzerland lose momentum? How well protected is the central space when possession is lost?

The available match reports cannot answer all of those questions.

And they are particularly important because Switzerland have not yet faced the most revealing situation of all: Xhaka returning to the team.

The better Switzerland may still include Xhaka

Switzerland finished their Nations League group with five wins and a draw, earning promotion to League A.

They achieved all six results without Xhaka.

That is now a substantial body of evidence. Switzerland no longer need to prove they can survive an occasional match without their captain.

The November victory over Scotland improves the case further because it came without September’s early numerical advantage.

But a winning team and a fully independent midfield structure are not necessarily the same thing.

The strongest evidence will arrive when Xhaka is available again.

If players such as Freuler, Jashari and Manzambi continue to receive meaningful responsibility for progression and tempo, Switzerland will have shown that those tasks no longer depend so heavily on one individual.

If most of the important decisions immediately flow back through Xhaka, the recent run may have represented a successful temporary adjustment rather than a lasting structural change.

That would not make the victories less impressive.

It would simply tell us what kind of progress Switzerland have made.

For now, they have answered one question convincingly: they can win without Xhaka.

The next step is not proving they no longer need him.

It is finding out whether they can remain just as capable of making decisions across the pitch when he returns.


Sources and further reading


Discover more from MATCHIQ

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

CONTINUE WITH MATCHIQ

Follow the next change in judgment.

Subscribe to new intelligence →

Sources & Corrections