STATUS: ROLE-FIT HYPOTHESIS
CONFIDENCE: MEDIUM
LAST VERIFIED: 4 Oct 2026
NEXT WATCH: Can Liverpool repeatedly get Wirtz closer to goal and into higher-value receiving zones?
Has Wirtz Really Declined — Or Has Liverpool Still Not Found How to Use Him?
Liverpool paid an initial £100 million, potentially rising to £116m, to sign Florian Wirtz from Bayer Leverkusen in 2025. Opta Analyst
More than a year later, the uncomfortable question has not disappeared.
Is he actually as good as Liverpool thought he was?
His first season did not deliver the superstar numbers many expected: seven goals and eight assists in 49 appearances.
The new season has not immediately changed the story either. After five Premier League games in 2026-27, Wirtz has played 404 minutes, with no goals and one assist. Across all competitions, that becomes six appearances and one assist. Opta Analyst
If we stop there, the verdict is easy.
Liverpool spent enormous money.
The output has not matched it.
But MATCHIQ is interested in what happens when we go one layer deeper.
Because the evidence does not look like a player whose football ability has simply disappeared.
The creativity never disappeared
Last season was disappointing.
But Wirtz still created 95 chances from open play in all competitions.
That was comfortably the most of any Liverpool player — at least 27 more than anybody else in the squad. Opta Analyst
That distinction matters.
Not producing an assist is not the same thing as not creating anything.
It does not excuse the lack of end product.
A player bought for this kind of money eventually has to decide games.
But it does stop us from making the lazy jump from:
poor output
to:
poor player.
Those are not automatically the same thing.
This season makes the question even stranger
If Wirtz were shrinking from games, we might expect fewer ambitious actions.
Instead, some of the numbers have moved in the opposite direction.
After five league games this season, he has made 43 line-breaking passes, or 9.6 per 90 minutes.
Last season, that figure was 5.2 per 90.
He has also made 19 progressive passes and regained possession six times in the opposition’s final third. Opta Analyst
So one explanation already looks weak:
Wirtz is not hiding.
He is still trying to break lines.
He is still demanding involvement.
He is still working without the ball.
The harder question is:
Why can a player be doing more and still feel like he is influencing games less than expected?
That is where Liverpool’s role becomes interesting.
We have already seen what happens when his environment changes
There was a revealing period last season.
Across Wirtz’s first 20 Liverpool appearances, he averaged only 63.9 touches per 90 minutes.
At Leverkusen, his previous-season figure had been 83.6.
Later, across a 12-game Liverpool stretch, his involvement climbed to 81.9 touches per 90 — almost back to Leverkusen levels.
More importantly, he was not simply receiving extra safe possession.
His touches inside the opposition penalty area increased from:
5.0 per 90 → 7.6 per 90.
He also began receiving the ball more frequently around the edge of the box, particularly from the left side. Opta Analyst
And the production changed too.
After a long opening spell without a Premier League goal, Wirtz began turning that increased involvement into actual output. Opta Analyst
That does not prove Liverpool were entirely responsible for his earlier struggles.
It does give us something much more useful:
There is already evidence that where and how often Liverpool involve Wirtz can materially change what they get from him.
So perhaps the question should not begin with:
Why isn’t Wirtz scoring?
It should begin one step earlier:
Where is Liverpool giving him the ball?
Bournemouth showed why both sides matter
Now for the part that stops this becoming an excuse piece.
Wirtz was poor for significant periods against Bournemouth.
Only 26 of his 37 passes found a teammate — 70.3%.
He lost possession 15 times before being substituted after 71 minutes.
Several of those were not brilliant high-risk attempts.
They were simply poorly executed passes. Opta Analyst
So the argument that:
“Liverpool just aren’t using him properly.”
is too convenient.
Wirtz has responsibility too.
But the same match also gave us the other side of the story.
Iraola acknowledged that Wirtz started slowly, but said his second half improved as he found better positions to receive and turn.
Wirtz still created three chances, and his near-post run contributed to the sequence that produced Alexander Isak’s winning goal. Opta Analyst
Same player.
Same match.
Different positions.
Different influence.
That is worth paying attention to.
So is this a Wirtz problem or a Liverpool problem?
For now:
Both.
Wirtz has things he must fix himself.
His execution needs to be cleaner.
Good positions have to become decisive actions more often.
At some point, a £100m-plus attacking player cannot survive purely on explanations about underlying creativity.
Wirtz himself accepts that responsibility. Before the Bournemouth game, he said he expects himself to help decide matches and acknowledged Liverpool’s attackers need to become more effective at finishing games. Liverpool FC
But Liverpool also have a job.
Because Wirtz is not at his best when football becomes:
Give him the ball and hope something magical happens.
At Leverkusen, his danger came from connections.
Receive between lines.
Turn.
Draw a defender.
Find the next runner.
Move again.
Receive closer to goal.
His value was not simply possessing the ball.
It was making the next action more dangerous.
Liverpool therefore have to create those situations often enough for that ability to matter.
Liverpool bought Wirtz, not a microwave
The fee creates a funny expectation.
Pay £100m, plug player in, press button.
Ding. World-class performance ready.
Football does not work like that.
Of course, elite players should adapt.
The fee cannot become a permanent excuse.
But when a club spends this much money on a specific type of player, the club also has to understand what it has bought.
If Wirtz is most dangerous when he can:
receive → turn → combine → release the next runner
then simply putting his name in the starting XI does not maximise the investment.
You can buy an expensive key.
It still needs the right lock.
RED TEAM: Maybe this is simply who Wirtz is in England
There is a much harsher interpretation.
Jamie Carragher has argued that Liverpool may not be watching a player suffering from poor form at all.
His concern is that this may simply be the level Wirtz provides in the Premier League, and he has questioned whether Wirtz currently deserves to start for Liverpool. Opta Analyst
That argument deserves to stay on the table.
Wirtz is no longer two months into his Liverpool career.
He has completed an entire season in England.
“Still adapting” cannot remain an unlimited excuse.
And his Bournemouth performance showed that tactical context cannot explain every misplaced pass or poor decision.
There is a simple way to test the two explanations.
Give Wirtz better conditions.
Then watch what happens.
MATCHIQ READ
The evidence currently supports a narrower conclusion than either extreme.
It is too early to say:
Wirtz is not good enough.
It is also too easy to say:
Liverpool are entirely responsible.
The cleaner read is:
Wirtz has continued to show the underlying actions that made him an elite creator, but Liverpool have not yet consistently converted those qualities into decisive output.
Last season showed that increasing his involvement — especially closer to the penalty area — coincided with a significant improvement in his influence. Opta Analyst
This season shows that he is still attempting to break lines and contribute without the ball. Opta Analyst
But Bournemouth showed the other truth:
A good environment cannot complete the pass for him.
Liverpool can help him find the socket.
Wirtz still has to switch the light on.
What we watch next
Forget whether he scores in the next game.
The more important signal is:
Can Iraola consistently get Wirtz receiving around the edge of the box and in the left half-space while facing goal?
Then watch what follows.
Do his box touches rise?
Does his chance creation remain high?
Does his expected-assist output improve?
Do those actions finally become goals and assists?
If Liverpool improve the conditions and Wirtz’s production rises with them, the evidence moves towards:
Liverpool had not been extracting enough from him.
If the positions improve, the involvement improves, and the decisive output still does not—
then MATCHIQ has to update the judgement too.
The problem starts moving back towards the player.
Current Read
HYPOTHESIS
Confidence: Medium
Wirtz now has enough Liverpool evidence that everything cannot simply be dismissed as adaptation.
But Iraola’s version of Liverpool is still young, and the team has not yet established a stable way of maximising him.
So there is no verdict yet.
First, give Wirtz the conditions where his best football should appear.
Then we can find out whether Liverpool still have an activation problem—
or a Wirtz problem.
